Best Toaster Oven For Frozen Pizza Review In 2021

Want to join the pizza club? If you’re in a hurry, you may want to grab a frozen pizza on your next grocery shopping trip.

To make it taste as close to restaurant quality as possible, you’ll need a good toaster oven.

And lucky for you – we have a guide ready to help you find the best toaster oven for frozen pizza in 2021! 

Read right on to find out everything you’ll need to reach pizza nirvana today!

Review Of The 5 Best Toaster Oven For Frozen Pizza

1.Breville Countertop Electric Toaster Oven: Best Pick

Why You’ll Love It:

If nothing else, you will love this breville toaster oven purely for its capacity. It's as spacious as they get. It isn't exactly cheap in terms of pricing, but it's the best quality oven in its range. 

This compact smart oven delivers fast and consistent cooking temperature for perfect result. Using the Smart Element IQ, you get the most consistent heat output. That's not common for a lot of toaster ovens. 

However, the best thing is that, this toaster comes with a dedicated temperature setting for pizza. It baked pizza evenly and in the shortest amount of time in our test. Its capabilities go beyond pizza. With eight versatile cooking functions, you can quickly set a variety of preset cooking modes for bagels, cookies, broiling, toasting and re-heating.

This toaster even has enough space to bake 4 slices of toast at a time or roast a whole chicken. If you want to speed up your cooking – the Turbo Convection Mode kicks in.

Potential Issues:

While it deserves a praise for its capacity, it does have a few caveats. The larger size means some cooking modes will take longer to heat it. A word of warning is that this oven tends to get very hot when in use. 

The biggest downfall is not being able to wash the accessories in a dishwasher. This might tack on some extra cleaning time.

Bottom Line:

Worth it for frequent pizza eaters. If you don't mind some extra cleaning time, you should go for it. It might not be the cheapest appliance on the market, but it's well worth its asking price.

Also Read: Best Toaster Oven With Rotisserie Function Review And Guide

2. Cuisinart TOA-60 Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer

Why You’ll Love It:

It might not be the best toaster oven for pizza, but it certainly is the best toaster oven with an air fryer. If you've a craving for fast food, you will certainly love its versatility. 

The air frying option lets you go beyond just pizza and bagels. This brings things like crispy french fries, doughnuts, and delicious chicken wings to the table! The large capacity air fryer basket able to fry a 3lbs of juicy chicken wings evenly and quickly. 

This is another toaster oven that easily fits a 12-inch pizza. You can even bake bread or broil steak with this unit. This oven warms up very fast. Despite being powered by a convection fan, it’s surprisingly quiet. You won’t hear it buzz or whirr during cooking. 

Interior lights are a feature you’ll come to appreciate when baking pizza. Safety comes first, of course, so as soon as you pop the door open – it will shut off.

For your money, this toaster oven comes with some heavy duty cooking accessories including, oven rack, baking pan, air fryer rack/basket etc.

Potential Issues:

There is a problem with the timer on this model. Not being digital, the mechanical timer is a bit inaccurate. This is very crucial for baking frozen pizza, as a few minutes longer can equal burnt food. 

Other than that, the air fryer doesn’t seem to retain its cooking power when you load it full. It might be an issue if you are making large batches of chicken wings or doughnuts.

Bottom Line:

Putting the cons aside, this is still a great toaster oven for frozen pizza! It would be perfect for someone who isn’t looking to bake pizza exclusively. If you’re into variety and love fast food – you are going to love this one!

3. Oster Digital Toaster Oven: Budget Pick

Why You’ll Love It:

This model by Oster is easily the best toaster oven for frozen pizza in its range. It can bake raw pizza, too. The temperature range lets you take full control. Tweak your temperatures and times to your heart’s content. 

With 7 cooking presets, it will allow you to quickly operate it and cook your favorite foods. You could use it to bake a 12-inch pizza in no time. With convection baking, you don’t have to worry about the baking time.

In addition to baking pizza, this oven is also does an admiral job of roasting chicken, baking cakes, warming up various things with consistent result. This high quality countertop oven incudes two oven racks, a durable baking pan and  a removable crumb tray. 

This oven supports two rack positions. This will allow you to get more cooking space especially for roasting a long golden brown chicken.

The touch buttons are easy to read and press. This oven even comes with a curved handle for easy lifting. The crumb tray is easy to clean with just tap water.

Potential Issues:

A lot of users report that this toaster oven gets very hot while its in use. While it doesn’t come with oven mitts, there is another issue. It’s more of an annoyance. You get a baking pan to go with it. The problem is that it won’t fit inside, making it completely useless.

Bottom Line:

You should be getting this if you make frozen pizza every day. You won’t find another model that does it as well or as quickly. Additional cooking functions make it easier to bake things other than pizza. Overall, minor inconveniences aside, it’s a pretty good budget toaster oven for a regular pizza eater!

4. Breville Large Toaster Oven: Best For 16-Inch Pizza

Why You’ll Love It:

It’s time for a powerhouse entry on our list! This breville toaster oven takes things to another level! It comes with quite a few goodies, so you’ll be ready to start baking right out of the box. 

This smart toaster does so much more than bake! It can convection bake, broil, proof, roast and does it all quickly.

Breville put its trademark Element IQ technology to a great use. It will easily bake a large 16’’ pizza and 14 pound chicken evenly. The dual convection fan ensures greater control over your cooking. It also makes sure the fast and even heat distribution for air frying and roasting. 

This oven easily supports most 9 x 13 inch pans and 12 cup muffin trays, which can be used for baking  lasagna, brownies, and cakes etc. for family parties.

There is bright interior lighting which lets you see your food progression without opening the door. A sleek LCD helps you navigate through features seamlessly.

Potential Issues:

It might be too heavy to move around freely. If you’re going to place it somewhere, make sure you don’t have to move it a lot. Also, the broiler setting is very powerful. You might need to think of a safe way to place it in your kitchen. And while it will work faster than a regular oven, it will consume more energy.

Bottom Line:

An excellent choice for anyone who is looking for a multi-purpose toaster oven with seriously large capacity. It has amazing cooking power and great versatility. It might not take it easy on the electricity, but it is the fastest cooking one. If you want to bake  pizza for a party and want it fast – this is the perfect choice. 

5.BLACK+DECKER Countertop Toaster Oven

Why You’ll Love It:

This Black+Decker monster is going to be the closest you’ll get to a toaster oven for 16-inch pizza. It can cook a 14’’ pizza in no time. The large interior is something not a lot of models can boast. It is durable and very easy to use. 

The controls are very intuitive. It doesn’t have a huge learning curve. Top it all off with a beautiful design and you have perfection. The large glass door allows you to see the interior. The size is perfect for small kitchen counter. If you are the hardcore pizza lover and eat it every day, this is for you! 

This toaster comes with some useful cooking utensils including, Bake Pan, Broil & Toasting Rack etc. 

Potential Issues:

The only known issue is that the timer tends to get stuck. This makes it slightly unreliable. You’ll have to pay extra attention to anything you cook in there. If you are into manual deep dives, prepare to be confused. The way the guidelines are written makes it eyebrow-raising at the very least.

Bottom Line:

This is for someone who eats, lives and breathes pizza. Not for the faint of heart. You're going to love all of the features especially the speed. It can fit larger pizzas than other appliances in its range. It's also a great pick for college students or any individual who doesn't like to spend too much money for a kitchen appliance.

Toaster oven VS microwave Reheating: Which one would be best for Cooking pizza?

While you can cook a pizza in a microwave, it doesn't necessarily mean it will come out good. Microwaves offer certain flexibility and temperature control most toaster ovens don't. 

That's not to say that toaster ovens fall short. The two appliances do different things. Toaster ovens can broil food, roast vegetables, and nicely crisp and brown a variety of pastries. As such, it would be perfect for a pizza.

A microwave might seem the more convenient choice. Microwaves cook in a way that isn't good for a pizza. No matter which amount of time or heating intensity you use, the pizza will come out dry and chewy.

Microwaves are best for heating things like soups, teas, or stews. Everything that has more liquid is going to cook better in a microwave. Toaster ovens might take longer to preheat and more effort to clean. But a microwave will never let you have a crispy, golden pizza to crunch on.

Best Toaster oven For Pizza: A Buyers Guide

Capacity and size:

These are going to be the most critical factors. How big is the pizza you usually eat? If you don’t like them small, get a toaster oven that fits a 12-inch or 16-inch pizza. This way, you won’t have to cut it in halves before baking. Smaller pizzas mean you’ll want a smaller oven. Also, don’t forget to check how big your kitchen is. So that, it can easily accommodates your oven.

Rack position:

The rack position will limit your toaster oven’s space. So, it’s essential to know how much space you have. The wire racks that you place the food on can be different. Single ones will let you have more space, but double means you’ll be able to cook more at a time. 

Are they removable? Are there more slots you can put them inside? Being able to manipulate and move them around makes it easier to control the baking process.

Cooking features:

Are you planning to bake pizza frequently? The pizza setting is a must! Having this setting will let you set the timer and temperature faster. Most standard models come with presets for Pizza, Bagel, Broil, Reheat, Toast, Bake, or Brown. These can be useful if you want to make more than a pizza quickly.

Temperature Controls:

You want to make sure your controls are as intuitive as they get. If you can, opt out for a model that has electronic touchpads. Numbered dials will do too. Some dials don’t have the labels pointed out too clearly. Avoid ones that you can’t read with ease. 

While you’re looking for additional controls, you will want to get a model with interior lights. It will makes it easier for you to watch the pizza during baking. 

Timers and alerts are great ways for you to know when your food is ready. They are minor conveniences and aren’t essential but are worth going after.

Useful accessories & additional features:

Toaster ovens, like many appliances, come with extra goodies sometimes. They can be as simple as a crumb tray and a crisper sheet. You could also get a toaster oven liner or spare baking racks. That’s about it for the simpler models. 

The more upscale side of the range comes with better accessories. These goodies can be fancy pizza stones, broiler racks, or baking trays.

It’s important to remember that your toaster oven won’t be able to fit standard bakeware. You might need to assemble a custom baking kit for your needs.

How do you cook frozen pizza in a toaster oven without drying it out?

Do you have a late-night pizza craving? Looking to bake a quick but delicious meal? The toaster oven has you covered! While you can cook a frozen pizza in a microwave, doing so in a toaster oven is better.

If you are looking for perfectly melting cheese and crunchy crusts - you've come to the right place! Read below to make sure your first frozen pizza comes out just right!

Step One: Ensure Proper Sizing Of your Pizza

Make sure that your toaster oven can fit the size of the frozen pizza. If you can't put it inside as is, you might have to cut it into halves. If you slice it, it won’t be able to hold the toppings in place as it bakes. 

Cutting it may result in toppings overflowing and falling into the toaster oven’s interior. You can use a toaster-oven safe baking tray to prevent this. If you do, the bottom of your pizza won’t be as crispy as you might like.

Step Two: Select Appropriate Temperature

Preheat your toaster oven to the highest temperature setting it offers. The ideal range is 375 - 425 F°, depending on the brand and model. Ten minutes should be long enough for a larger model to preheat. Five minutes if the appliance is smaller. 

Set your oven to bake or convection, depending on what is available. Some toaster ovens will have a pizza cooking mode. You can put it to use. Whatever you do, never use the broil function. It will scorch the toppings and undercook the bottom of your pizza.

Step Three: Place The Pizza Into The Oven

Remove the frozen pizza from its packaging and insert it into the toaster oven. You will get better results if you don’t use a baking tray. It’s essential to allow the heat to reach both sides of the pizza. This way, you’ll get better browning and crisping. Try to put the pizza closer to the top heater, but not too close.

Step Four: Keep An Eye When Baking

Make sure that you are checking on your pizza as it bakes. If your toaster oven has hot or cold spots, this might affect the cooking speed. In general terms, if you set your toaster oven to the highest temperature – it should take up to 7 minutes. The baking time depends on a lot of factors. You must monitor it to make sure the pizza doesn't burn.

Step Five: Safely Remove The Pizza

There are a few ways to know that your frozen pizza is ready to eat. Once the cheese starts to melt - it’s time to take it out of the oven. The toppings might get a light brown color too. You should be able to see the cheese slowly starting to bubble, too. 

Remove the pizza from the toaster oven, safely turning it off after use. Be careful not to burn your hands! Serve it up, garnish with fresh ingredients or sauces of your preference, if any, and - Buon appetito!

FAQ's:

Q1: Can you bake a pizza in a toaster oven?

Ans: You could! Some toaster ovens have pizza cooking modes. What you do need to pay attention to is the temperature. Heating elements have different positions on toaster ovens. Because of this, you may be exposing your pizza to higher temperatures. Usually, the top heaters are more robust than the bottom ones. 

Be wary of the toaster oven's hot and cold spots. Those might end up burning your pizza on top and undercooking the bottom. Keep an eye out for it and adjust your temperature. You could make restaurant-quality pizza this way.

Q2: Can you cook frozen food in a toaster oven?

Ans: You can – but not in the container it comes in. It says so on most frozen food labels. You aren't supposed to cook them in a toaster oven. Instant food packaging often contains plastic. It may be hazardous when exposed to high temperatures. 

With the conventional oven, this would be a non-issue. They are bigger, more spacious, and have more accurate temperature controls.

Toaster ovens transfer heat faster due to their size. The heat might compromise the plastic on the packaging. While you shouldn't do it, there is a safer alternative. 

You could unpack the frozen food. Then, transfer it into a toaster-oven safe container. It will eliminate the fire hazards and most of the safety risks.

Q3: How long do you put pizza in the toaster oven?

Ans: That would largely depend on the model of your toaster oven. There are no universal settings for every toaster oven. But, generally speaking, you could preheat the toaster oven to 350 F°. This is the best temperature to cook pizza in a toaster oven.

At this temperature, it should take anywhere between 3 and 7 minutes for the pizza to bake. Make sure you are always looking after the pizza as it is baking. This ensures any potential hot or cold spots in the toaster oven won't over or undercook..

Q4: Should you preheat your toaster oven?

Ans: It depends on what you are planning to bake. But the answer is mostly yes. The reason behind this is the way the heating elements of a toaster oven behave. 

For most of the models, the top heating element is the one that heats the most. Some toaster ovens will cycle between both heating elements to maintain a somewhat even temperature over time. 

If you put your food in without preheating, the heaters will most likely brown or even blacken one side of the dish. Preheating is not that bad on toaster ovens. Most of them tend to preheat quite quickly. It's recommended that you preheat your toaster oven to the desired temperature at least 5 minutes before you put anything inside.

Q5: What temperature should I use if I want crispy crust?

Ans: If you want to get a crispy crust pizza then, you'll need to set the temperature up to 400°F. If your oven has a convection mode, you may turn it on. This will significantly reduce the cooking time and ensure even baking.

Final Words:

Any one of the toaster ovens above will do just fine. It’s just a matter of preference for certain things. If you are looking for top notch quality – this would have to go over to Breville Countertop Electric Toaster Oven. Top of the line, great performance all at a decent price. If you are looking to take it to the next level – Black+Decker has you covered. If you've any specific recommendation about the best toaster oven for frozen pizza, feel free to share with us by comment.

Article Resources:

1. https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1992-09-10-9203220616-story.html

2. https://www.hunker.com/12146655/how-does-a-toaster-oven-work